- en
In coastal areas, offshore platforms and other scenarios with frequent salt spray exposure, choosing between 304 and 316L stainless steel pipes is a top concern for project teams. The former is cheaper, while the latter has stronger corrosion resistance. How long can 304 last in high-salt environments? Is 316L a must? This article gives you straightforward answers with simple analysis and data.
The corrosion threat in high-salt environments all comes from chloride ions (Cl⁻). Chloride ions in marine salt spray, coastal groundwater, and chemical brine can pierce the "protective layer" (oxide film Cr₂O₃) on the stainless steel surface, causing local rust (pitting), crevice corrosion, and eventually water leakage—both dangerous and costly.
Whether stainless steel resists corrosion depends entirely on how tough this oxide film is. Once chloride ions destroy it, the metal substrate will rust faster. So choosing a pipe essentially depends on its ability to "resist chloride ions".
Both 304 and 316L are common stainless steels, but their salt resistance differs greatly—all due to molybdenum (Mo).
304 contains no molybdenum, with a composition of 18%-20% chromium and 8%-10.5% nickel. It works when chloride ions are low, but once the concentration exceeds 50ppm (e.g., near the coast), the corrosion risk rises sharply.
316L adds 2%-3% molybdenum to 304, which forms a stronger "protective layer" with chromium—its chloride ion resistance is 10 times higher, able to withstand up to 500ppm of high-concentration chloride ions. Additionally, "L" stands for low carbon, so it won’t rust easily after welding, making the pipeline more reliable.
316L isn’t mandatory for all high-salt environments. The key factors are chloride ion concentration, temperature, pressure, and project lifespan. Three scenarios make it clear:
7. Scenarios requiring 316L: Coastal outdoor pipelines, seawater desalination equipment, offshore platforms, or chemical pipelines with chloride ions exceeding 50ppm. 304 will leak in 3-5 years here, while 316L can last 15-20 years, making it more cost-effective in the long run.
8. Scenarios where 304 can be used cautiously: Areas over 5km from the coastline with shelter, or groundwater pipelines with chloride ions ≤50ppm. Conditions: thicker pipe walls, annual anti-corrosion treatment, project lifespan within 5 years, and regular corrosion inspections.
9. Extreme scenarios requiring higher-grade materials: If chloride ions exceed 500ppm (e.g., concentrated brine), or temperature exceeds 80℃/pressure exceeds 16MPa, even 316L is insufficient. 2205 duplex steel or 904L super stainless steel is needed.
IV. How Long Does 304 Last in High-Salt Environments? 3-10 Years, Depending on Environment and Maintenance
304’s lifespan isn’t fixed—it depends entirely on environmental conditions and maintenance. The industry generally divides it into three categories:
10. Harsh environment (chloride ions >100ppm): Coastal outdoor pipelines or pipes in direct contact with seawater. 304 will rust locally in 1 year and definitely leak in 3-5 years. Forcing its use will lead to higher costs from frequent maintenance.
11. Medium environment (chloride ions 20-100ppm): Non-outdoor pipelines in coastal industrial parks or low-salt groundwater pipelines. With 1-2 annual cleanings and anti-corrosion treatments, 304 can last 5-8 years, but corrosion inspections are needed every six months.
12. Mild environment (chloride ions ≤20ppm): Indoor pipelines in coastal cities over 10km from the coastline. 304 can last 8-10 years with regular maintenance.
Core conclusion: The higher the chloride ion concentration, the shorter 304’s lifespan. Regular maintenance can extend its life, but it can’t change its weak salt resistance. |
Choosing a pipe is about balancing "performance", "cost" and "lifespan". Remember three principles:
• If the project lasts over 10 years or involves core pipelines (e.g., subsea pipes), choose 316L directly to avoid major losses later;
• For temporary projects, auxiliary pipelines, or budgets with low chloride ion concentrations, 304 is acceptable—but plan the replacement time in advance;
• No matter which material is used, clean welds thoroughly during installation, and perform regular cleaning and anti-corrosion treatments to reduce rust risks.
Summary: 304 isn’t completely forbidden in high-salt environments, but 316L—with molybdenum-enhanced corrosion resistance—is a more reliable long-term choice. It’s recommended to have professional institutions test the environmental chloride ion concentration first, then select materials based on project needs to avoid waste or risks.
